What Is the Difference Between Legal Separation and Divorce in New York?
Legal separation and divorce both address a marriage that is not working, but they produce different legal results. A divorce, granted under Domestic Relations Law § 170, ends the marriage completely, dissolving the legal relationship between the spouses and resolving property, support, and custody issues in a final judgment. A legal separation, most often established either through a court-ordered judgment of separation or through a written, signed, and acknowledged separation agreement between the spouses, allows spouses to live apart and formalize terms covering property, support, and children, without ending the marriage itself. Neither spouse is free to remarry after a legal separation, since the marriage remains legally intact. New York law also connects the two: living apart for six months or more under a separation judgment, or under a written separation agreement, with proof that its terms were substantially performed, is itself one of the seven grounds for divorce under Domestic Relations Law § 170(5) and § 170(6). This means a separation can function both as a standalone arrangement and as a later pathway to a full divorce judgment if the spouses decide to proceed that way. Call (888) 437-7747 to request a consultation about which option fits a specific situation.
How Separation and Divorce Relate Under New York Law
A legal separation under New York law can take two forms. The first is a judgment of separation entered by a court, typically after a contested or agreed proceeding addressing the same kinds of issues, property, support, and children, that a divorce case would address. The second is a written separation agreement, a contract the spouses sign and have acknowledged in the manner required to record a deed, covering those same issues without any court proceeding to create it. Either form allows spouses to live apart with defined terms in place while remaining legally married.
The connection to divorce comes from Domestic Relations Law § 170(5) and § 170(6). Under § 170(5), a divorce may be granted where the spouses lived apart for six months or more pursuant to a decree or judgment of separation, with proof of substantial performance of its terms. Under § 170(6), a divorce may be granted where the spouses lived apart for the same period pursuant to a written, acknowledged separation agreement, again with proof of substantial performance. In both cases, the separation itself becomes the evidentiary basis the court needs to grant the divorce judgment later, without the spouses needing to prove fault or wait for a separate no-fault sworn statement. A divorce judgment then goes further than a separation ever does: it terminates the marriage, after which either spouse is free to remarry, something a legal separation, however formal, does not permit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a legal separation end a marriage in New York?
No. A legal separation, whether established by a court judgment or by a written separation agreement, allows spouses to live apart and formalize terms covering property, support, and children, but the marriage itself remains legally intact until a divorce judgment is entered.
Can a separated spouse remarry in New York?
No. Because a legal separation does not end the marriage, neither spouse is free to remarry while the separation is in place. Only a divorce judgment under Domestic Relations Law § 170 legally terminates the marriage and allows remarriage.
What are the two ways to establish a legal separation in New York?
A legal separation can be established through a court-ordered judgment of separation, typically following a proceeding addressing property, support, and children, or through a written separation agreement signed and acknowledged by the spouses without a court proceeding.
Can a separation agreement later become the basis for a divorce?
Yes. Under Domestic Relations Law § 170(6), a divorce may be granted where the spouses lived apart for six months or more pursuant to a written, acknowledged separation agreement, with proof that its terms were substantially performed.
Can a judgment of separation later become the basis for a divorce?
Yes. Under Domestic Relations Law § 170(5), a divorce may be granted where the spouses lived apart for six months or more pursuant to a decree or judgment of separation, with proof that its terms were substantially performed.
Why would a couple choose separation instead of divorce?
Reasons vary by family and are personal to each couple’s circumstances. Because a legal separation formalizes terms without ending the marriage, it can serve couples who want defined arrangements in place while they decide whether to reconcile or eventually proceed to divorce.
Is a separation agreement the same as a divorce settlement agreement?
They can cover similar ground, property division, support, and custody, but a separation agreement does not by itself end the marriage. If the spouses later divorce using that agreement as the basis under Domestic Relations Law § 170(6), its terms are typically carried forward into the divorce judgment.
How long do spouses have to be separated before filing for divorce?
Domestic Relations Law § 170(5) and § 170(6) both require the spouses to have lived apart for at least six months under the applicable separation judgment or agreement before that separation can serve as the ground for a divorce.
Does either party have to prove fault to divorce after a separation?
No. Divorcing based on an existing separation judgment or separation agreement under Domestic Relations Law § 170(5) or § 170(6) requires proof of the separation itself and substantial performance of its terms, not proof of fault by either spouse.
What happens to a separation agreement’s terms once a divorce is finalized?
When a separation agreement is used as the basis for a divorce under Domestic Relations Law § 170(6), its terms are generally incorporated into the divorce proceeding, though the specific treatment depends on the agreement’s own language and how the parties and the court address it.
Attorney Background
Mr. Sris, Owner and Founder of Law Offices Of SRIS, P.C., is a former prosecutor who founded the firm in 1997 and is admitted to practice in Virginia, Maryland, the District of Columbia, New Jersey, and New York. Mr. Sris and the firm’s Of Counsel attorneys help spouses across New York decide between pursuing a legal separation, whether by court judgment or written agreement, and proceeding directly to a divorce, and later help spouses use an existing separation as the basis for a divorce filing under Domestic Relations Law § 170(5) or § 170(6) when that becomes the goal. The firm’s Of Counsel attorneys contract directly with the firm and prepare separation judgments, separation agreements, and divorce filings alike. The firm does not offer free consultations. Spouses can request a scheduled consultation, and reach the 24/7 phone intake line at (888) 437-7747.
Related Pages
- Legal Separation Lawyer New York
- Separation Agreement Lawyer New York
- Uncontested Divorce Lawyer New York
- Divorce Lawyer New York
- What Are Grounds for Divorce in New York
This page provides general information and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Case results depend on a variety of factors unique to each case. Results may vary.
Attorney Advertising. Law Offices Of SRIS, P.C., principal office: 4008 Williamsburg Court, Fairfax, VA 22032. By appointment. Call (888) 437-7747 to schedule.
Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.