Which Auto Insurance Option Did I Choose New Jersey

It is a fair question and most New Jersey drivers cannot answer it. When a policy is written, the state requires a choice between two lawsuit options, and that choice determines whether you can claim for pain and suffering after a collision or only for economic losses. The election was made on a form, often years ago, sometimes by a spouse or a parent, and it is rarely mentioned again until an adjuster raises it. The good news is that the answer is recorded and can be found. The less welcome news is that it may not have been your choice at all. Call (888) 437-7747 if you need help working out where you stand.

On this page

The Choice New Jersey Drivers Make

New Jersey’s automobile insurance framework, reshaped by the reform legislation commonly called AICRA, requires the person buying a policy to select a lawsuit option. One option preserves the ordinary right to claim for non-economic loss, meaning pain and suffering. The other, which carries a lower premium, limits that right to a defined set of injury categories. The limitation option is often referred to as the verbal threshold, and it is the one most policies carry, because premium is what most people compare when a policy is written.

The distinction is not about whether you can bring a claim. Economic losses such as medical expenses and lost earnings are pursued in the ordinary way under either option. What changes is whether a claim for pain and suffering is available at all, and under the limitation option it is available only where the injury falls into one of the listed categories. That is why the same collision, with the same injuries, can be worth very different amounts to two drivers whose policies differ.

Where the Answer Is Recorded

The election is made on the coverage selection form completed when the policy was written or last rewritten. That form is the primary record and it is the document that matters if the question is ever disputed. The declarations page issued with each renewal usually indicates the option as well, generally in the section describing the bodily injury and personal injury protection coverages, though the wording varies between insurers and is not always obvious to a reader who does not know what to look for.

If neither document is to hand, the insurer and the producer who placed the policy both hold copies. A written request asking for the coverage selection form and confirmation of the lawsuit option in force on the date of the collision is the direct route, and it is worth making the request in writing so that the answer and its date are recorded. Keep whatever comes back, because the option in force on the date of the collision is what governs, not the option in force today.

Why It May Not Be Your Own Choice That Governs

This is the part that surprises people. The lawsuit option attaches to a household rather than only to the person who signed the form. It generally binds the named insured, a spouse, and resident relatives in the household who are not themselves named insureds under a separate policy of their own. An adult child living at home, a spouse who never saw the paperwork, and a relative who does not drive can all find their claims governed by an election made by someone else.

The consequence for an injured person is procedural rather than abstract: the first task is to identify every policy that might reach them, not just the one covering the car they were in. A passenger, a pedestrian or a cyclist is not automatically outside the restriction, because what matters is the policies covering their own household. Working this out early is important, because it determines what has to be proved medically and how quickly that proof has to be assembled.

What the Answer Changes in Practice

If the policy carries the limitation option, a claim for pain and suffering requires the injury to fall within one of the statutory categories, established by objective clinical evidence, and it carries a certification requirement from a treating physician with a short deadline attached. That means the medical documentation created while treating is what decides the claim, and it means the work has to begin immediately rather than when the dispute crystallizes.

If the policy carries the option without that limitation, the non-economic claim proceeds without the threshold, though everything else about proving the case remains the same. Either way the answer should be established at the outset. A claimant who assumes the wrong option can under-document a claim that would have succeeded, or spend effort on a threshold argument that was never needed. This area of the law continues to develop, and how particular fact patterns are treated is not static, so the current position should be confirmed with counsel rather than assumed.

If You Were Insured Outside New Jersey

Drivers insured in another state who are injured in New Jersey, and New Jersey residents injured across a state line, face an additional question about which state’s rules apply before anyone reaches the merits. New Jersey law can treat certain policies written by insurers doing business in the state as subject to the threshold even where the policy itself was issued elsewhere, a result that out-of-state drivers rarely anticipate. Where a collision has connections to more than one jurisdiction, that analysis belongs at the very start, before any position is taken with an insurer.

Why So Many Drivers Do Not Know the Answer

The election is presented at the least memorable moment in the life of a policy: while the coverage is being priced, alongside a set of other choices, and usually with the premium difference as the visible variable. The consequence of the choice is invisible until a collision happens, which may be many renewals later. By then the form has been filed away, the producer may have changed, and the household may include people who were not present when the choice was made.

There is also a structural reason. The two options are described in the paperwork in statutory language rather than in plain terms, and a reader without context can easily take the limitation option to be a restriction on something technical rather than on the largest component of a personal injury claim. None of that changes the effect of the election, but it does explain why the question is worth answering deliberately rather than assuming that a decision consciously made at the time will be remembered accurately now.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where exactly do I look on my policy?

Start with the coverage selection form completed when the policy was written, which is the controlling record. Then check the declarations page issued at the most recent renewal, where the lawsuit option is usually indicated near the bodily injury and personal injury protection entries. Wording differs between insurers, so if the language is ambiguous, ask the insurer in writing to confirm the option that was in force on the date of the collision.

I did not buy the policy. Does the option still apply to me?

It may. The election generally binds the named insured, a spouse, and resident relatives in the household who are not themselves named insureds under their own policy. That is why it is common for someone who never saw the form to be governed by it. The practical step is to identify every policy in the household rather than only the one covering the vehicle involved in the collision.

Can I change my option after an accident?

No. What governs is the option in force on the date of the collision. Changing the election going forward affects future claims and does nothing for one that has already arisen. It is still worth reviewing the election for the future, because the premium difference is modest compared with the difference in what can be recovered.

Does the limitation option stop me recovering my medical bills?

No. The restriction applies to non-economic loss, meaning pain and suffering. Medical expenses and lost earnings are handled separately, through personal injury protection benefits and through the economic component of a claim, and they are not restricted by the lawsuit option. A claimant who cannot satisfy the threshold may still have a meaningful economic claim.

The adjuster says the threshold blocks my claim. Is that the end?

Not necessarily. Whether the threshold is satisfied is a question about medical proof that gets resolved on the records as they eventually stand, and an early assertion by an insurer is a position rather than a determination. It is usually made before the medical evidence is complete. What matters is whether the treating physicians are recording measured, objective findings, and whether care is continuous.

What should I do first?

Find the coverage selection form and declarations page for every policy in your household, and if you cannot, request them from the insurer in writing. Keep treating without unexplained gaps. Then get advice quickly, because if the limitation option applies there is a certification requirement with a short deadline and it depends on medical proof that has to exist already. Reach our location at (888) 437-7747 to arrange a consultation.

Working With Law Offices Of SRIS, P.C.

Which lawsuit option governs an injured person is a question of documents, and it is worth answering in the first week rather than after an insurer raises it.

Mr. Sris, Owner and Founder of Law Offices Of SRIS, P.C., is a former prosecutor and is admitted in Virginia, Maryland, the District of Columbia, New Jersey, and New York. The firm has been practicing since 1997. Mr. Sris and the firm’s Of Counsel attorneys handle matters across those jurisdictions, which matters here because neighbouring states apply materially different rules to the same accident, and where a claim is brought can decide whether it proceeds at all. Mr. Sris brings a background in accounting and information systems from George Mason University, applied to complex financial and technology-related cases.

The firm serves Northern Virginia from 1655 Fort Myer Dr, Suite 700, Room 719, Arlington, VA 22209 and central Virginia from 7400 Beaufont Springs Drive, Suite 300, Room 395, Richmond, VA 23225. By appointment. Call (888) 437-7747 to schedule. Request a consultation. Reach our location at (888) 437-7747.

This page provides general information about New Jersey automobile insurance lawsuit options and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Case results depend on a variety of factors unique to each case. Results may vary.

Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Attorney responsible for this advertising: Mr. Sris.

This answer covers New Jersey. Our page on personal injury lawyer New Jersey sets out the whole process from start to finish.